There is nothing like a Cherokee. They are so well mannered and do what you want...
I have flown all of them from the 140 to the 300 hp Cherokee Six and just love every minute!
I think the best four seater is the Cherokee D 180. It has huge useful load and just enough power and economy. Plus, I like the stubby little wings for taxiing past snowbanks and through tight grass fields.
The Arrow is nice, but there isn't much payoff in terms of speed for all the extra "stuff".
The Cherokee Six is just a pleasure to fly. It just flies itself! No doubt. it is the SUV of the fleet. The load carrying capabilities are UNREAL!
This pic was taken on the way to OSH 2005 in Dubois, PA.
Nice planes, guys!

CJ